Would you consider this a bug?

Not open for further replies.


We had a user that had been added to a DL under Message Delivery Restrictions > Accept messages from. He had been given the access to delivery to the "All Company" DL. This user had left the company. His mailbox had been removed from his account and the account disabled. The next time I tried to add another user to the "Accept messages from" it threw an error that it couldnt find the other user that is no longer with the company. The user that was terminated was not listed in the GUI as being allowed to send to the DL even though he was actually still in the list. To quickly resolve the issue, I gave him a mailbox and enabled his account. I was then able to see him in the list and remove him. I could then add users to the list. Given more time I am sure I could have removed him from the list via powershell using set-distributiongroup or something similar. I know someone will say just make sure you remove the user from all of the ""Accept messages from" lists but thats not really the answer to this issue as it is it not easy to determine what lists the user is in. I think the real issue is: Should the user be hidden from the GUI if he no longer has a mailbox? ...which causes an error each time another user is added...

What's your opinion?

Brian Desmond -MVP-

This is confusing but it's consistent across all of the Exchange UIs. By hiding the entries they don't have to handle the scenario of trying to display an object that's missing all sorts of fields.

I'd just use something like ADSIEdit in the future to remove the linked value from the group.

My Book - Active Directory, 4th Edition
My Blog - www.briandesmond.com
Not open for further replies.
Thread starter Similar threads Forum Replies Date
S steps to consider while adding additional exchange 2010 server Exchange Server Administration 4
E Outlook 2016 Inbox search bug Using Outlook 1
C address book "when sending email" bug? Using Outlook 0
Diane Poremsky iPhone and the Meeting Request Bug New Slipstick.com Articles 0
Diane Poremsky Outlook Connector Contact Sync Bug (Fixed) New Slipstick.com Articles 0
Diane Poremsky Add to Outlook Contacts Bug (Fixed) New Slipstick.com Articles 1
TheDavidSlight Daylight savings - another subtle bug ... Using Outlook 3
R A bug in calendar form? Using Outlook 2
P BCM 2013 Contacts Form Drop Down Box Bug BCM (Business Contact Manager) 1
W Midnight bug - Outlook Today & reminders Using Outlook 5
witzker Outlook bug when creating a user defined contact form? Using Outlook 1
mrje1 Assigned Categories keep getting deleted in mail, bug? How to fix if possible? Using Outlook 5
P connector categories bug Using Outlook.com accounts in Outlook 2
C Bug? Forwarded message body is blank Using Outlook 2
S Email Address Policy Bug?? Exchange Server Administration 5
B Outlook 2010 calendar month view colorisation bug Using Outlook 1
T Outlook 2007 Tracking bug? Using Outlook 2
E Bug in Outlook 2010 Conversation View? Using Outlook 1
J Bug in Outlook 2010 Using Outlook 2
M Outlook 2010 IMAP account management bug(s) Using Outlook 1
M Eliminate bug that closes my Outlook Using Outlook 3
K Exchange 2010 SP1 RU1 - Get-PublicFolderDatabase bug / documentation issue? Exchange Server Administration 6
E Changes to appointment reminder defaults on the File->Options-Calendar are not saved! Bug or feature? Using Outlook 3
D Outlook file download bug? Using Outlook 1
R Bug? Message size limit checked before attached images resized Using Outlook 1
S Can't see Sent To email address when using Outlook Connector. Seems to not sychronize. Is this a bug? Using Outlook 1
S Exchange 2010 Service Pack 1 bug with duplicate machine SIDs Exchange Server Administration 6
J Exchange 2010 SP1 and SCOM 2007 R2 Bug? Exchange Server Administration 5
T Exchange 2010 SP1 Mailbox export date filter problem - bug? Exchange Server Administration 9
T Exchange 2010 SP1 BUG - Import IsArchive Exchange Server Administration 41
A Outlook 2007 and 2010 Autosave bug Using Outlook 3
S Re: Exchange 2010 and Outlook 2007 folder bug Exchange Server Administration 5
J bug in converting eml files of wlm on import to outlook 2010 Using Outlook 7
R Proof Of Looping Bug in Reading Outlook Inbox From Access? Outlook VBA and Custom Forms 2
A 'Mark Unread' button - bug in Outlook 2010 RTM Using Outlook 11
A Outlook-Exchange bug??? Outlook VBA and Custom Forms 8
J Exchange 2010 and Outlook 2007 folder bug Exchange Server Administration 12
C Attachments collection bug ? Outlook VBA and Custom Forms 5
S Bug? Event ID 10154 (WinRM service failed to create the following SPNs...) Exchange Server Administration 24
Q Inspector Bug/Question Outlook VBA and Custom Forms 3
Q Outlook 2007 Add-in Bug with with Exchange - Long explanation Outlook VBA and Custom Forms 2
Similar threads