Outlook Anywhere vs Activesync and Enterprise Security

Status
Not open for further replies.

byteguy

Member
Outlook version
Outlook 2013 64 bit
Email Account
Exchange Server
I would like to deploy new MS Surface Pro 2s (SP2s) installed with Windows 8.1 and MS Office 2013. I will keep these outside the corporate firewall so that users can install non company standard apps (as they currently do on iPads). However, unlike with iPads, they can enjoy a fully featured MS Office experience for work related activities. However, the key ‘connection’ they will have to the corporate systems will be email.

I am responsible for my local office’s IT infrastructure which is limited to LAN connected desktops and a local domain for file and print services. Our Exchange environment recently was migrated to our HQ.

I have encountered a roadblock with corporate IT. I would like to use Outlook 2013 on the SP2s connecting via Outlook Anywhere when working remotely (as we do with existing company issued laptops). Corporate IT will only permit an Activesync connection, as is used with company issued iPads. I believe that Outlook 2013 will not work with Activesync which would require us to use the (sadly disappointing) Windows8.1 email client – it won’t be a great experience for our users.

I have countered various arguments regarding ActiveSync benefits (remote wipe, forced encryption, forced passwords) but have encountered one argument that I can’t readily answer. Corporate IT insist that their Exchange environment is more vulnerable if a user’s SP2 is connected to Exchange via Outlook Anywhere rather than Activesync and it becomes compromised by a virus, Trojan or other hack (by using personal apps such as Skype, iTunes, games, etc.).

I can’t find a definitive answer, in my searching, that compares the vulnerability of the enterprise Exchange server when connecting to compromised clients via Outlook Anywhere rather than ActiveSync.

Can anyone help as well as direct me to a MS issued paper that answers this in a manner that corporate IT, or I, can’t refute?
 

Diane Poremsky

Senior Member
Outlook version
Outlook 2016 32 bit
Email Account
Office 365 Exchange
I'm not sure why they are treating the surface any differently than the laptops? Both should be treated the same.

And yes, you are correct, outlook can't use ActiveSync - they'd have to use the builtin mail app or OWa.

IT is incorrect - outlook is secure against viruses. I don't have any documentation for security EAS vrs Outlookanywhere, but I believe they are both equally secure.
 

byteguy

Member
Outlook version
Outlook 2013 64 bit
Email Account
Exchange Server
I'm not sure why they are treating the surface any differently than the laptops? Both should be treated the same.

And yes, you are correct, outlook can't use ActiveSync - they'd have to use the builtin mail app or OWa.

IT is incorrect - outlook is secure against viruses. I don't have any documentation for security EAS vrs Outlookanywhere, but I believe they are both equally secure.

Thanks for your confirmation, Diane. In order for me to convince my IT HQ of this, I doubt that they would accept anything but an MS tech document or a paper from another credible third party analyst. Do you have any guidance as to where I will find such? I have already spent half a day in Google but drawing blanks. Another possible option is for a persuasive document that compares how a client connecting to Exchange via EAS is any different from one connecting via Outlook Anywhere, in particular, whether a compromised client can more easily gain access to the corporate Exchange environment. Please note that these SP2s will have Symantec Endpoint Protection (stand-alone) just as any domain connected laptop - except they will never join the domain.
 

Diane Poremsky

Senior Member
Outlook version
Outlook 2016 32 bit
Email Account
Office 365 Exchange
I'll see what i can find.

They'll only have access to the Exchange server either way.
 

byteguy

Member
Outlook version
Outlook 2013 64 bit
Email Account
Exchange Server
I'll see what i can find.

They'll only have access to the Exchange server either way.

Another related thought: while never having used it, doesn't MS offer its Office 365 suite, to enterprises and individuals, in a configuration that permits the client end to be a full blown Outlook client that connects via Outlook Anywhere to MS's Office 365 Exchange infrastructure? If so, could it be argued that MS has no way of knowing whether the client PCs connecting are compromised by some kind of malware? If this is the case, would they have any better protection from untrusted connecting clients than a enterprise would have with their own Exchange farm? I guess I am asking "if Outlook Anywhere is deemed safe by MS, with untrusted clients, why would an enterprise feel differently?" Any idea the approximate number of clients that Office 365 sees connecting via Outlook Anywhere?
 

Diane Poremsky

Senior Member
Outlook version
Outlook 2016 32 bit
Email Account
Office 365 Exchange
100% of the outlook clients connecting to office 365 use outlook anywhere - it's the only way. I have no idea of the number, but it's in the millions.

Did they give any specifics about why they think outlook anywhere is unsafe?
 

Diane Poremsky

Senior Member
Outlook version
Outlook 2016 32 bit
Email Account
Office 365 Exchange
i don't think these articles will help any - they cover it more from the angle of SSL and someone sniffing email or credentials, which would apply to ActiveSync too, rather than security from the standpoint of viruses and such. From the security/virus angle, the rpc connection is secure - a virus could only get in via email and outlook is secure against viruses.

http://social.technet.microsoft.com...0/thread/140eca3f-bea0-4e40-a74f-9ed7ede6cd3a

Understanding Security for Outlook Anywhere

http://technet.microsoft.com/en-us/library/bb430792.aspx

Securing Client Access Servers

http://technet.microsoft.com/en-us/library/bb400932.aspx
 

Diane Poremsky

Senior Member
Outlook version
Outlook 2016 32 bit
Email Account
Office 365 Exchange
I wonder if they read this article - http://www.computerworld.com/s/arti...nager_s_Journal_Closing_off_a_hole_in_Outlook

If so

1) ActiveSync is a problem too - users can add an account to any win8 computer. Once mail is downloaded to a surface, the user can do anything they want with it, just like they can with outlook.

2) "A few weeks ago, the manager of a local hotel called to tell us that the hotel staff had discovered over 1GB of our company email on the computer in the hotel lobby. " WTF? The problem isn't Outlook Anywhere, it's the idiot user who created an outlook profile on someone else's computer... i can't believe a computer in the hotel lobby has outlook or that they don't reimage nightly. Or that the user was dumb enough to set up a profile on it - they should be using OWA on public computers. But making users use active sync isn't going to prevent this, they can still create accounts in Mail apps on other computers - only educating users will prevent this.
 

byteguy

Member
Outlook version
Outlook 2013 64 bit
Email Account
Exchange Server
I wonder if they read this article - http://www.computerworld.com/s/arti...nager_s_Journal_Closing_off_a_hole_in_Outlook

If so

1) ActiveSync is a problem too - users can add an account to any win8 computer. Once mail is downloaded to a surface, the user can do anything they want with it, just like they can with outlook.

2) "A few weeks ago, the manager of a local hotel called to tell us that the hotel staff had discovered over 1GB of our company email on the computer in the hotel lobby. " WTF? The problem isn't Outlook Anywhere, it's the idiot user who created an outlook profile on someone else's computer... i can't believe a computer in the hotel lobby has outlook or that they don't reimage nightly. Or that the user was dumb enough to set up a profile on it - they should be using OWA on public computers. But making users use active sync isn't going to prevent this, they can still create accounts in Mail apps on other computers - only educating users will prevent this.

Thanks for all the links. I have already reviewed most of them. I also have sent across a 'request' to HQ to consider that seeks to draw comparisons to EAS but also relevance to our company owned SP2s (unlike the hotel faux-pas our data 'should' only be on the SP2). I can't answer your question on why they think OA is not secure as my initial feedback has been vague. The iniital position is that OA would connect an untrusted SP2 directly to their Exchange. I am trying to work through their concerns in a constructive way -- which I thought would benefit from a definitive MS document that would dispell their fears or, at least, categorically, clarify that OA expsoures are not greater that EAS exposures. I might find that their concerns are well placed but my research to date doesn't support this.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Similar threads
Thread starter Title Forum Replies Date
C outlook 2016 and outlook anywhere Using Outlook 1
R Outlook anywhere Using Outlook 1
M Autodiscover not configuring Outlook Anywhere Using Outlook 10
S Excel vba code to manage outlook web app Using Outlook 1
J outlook 2007 doesn't let me choose which .pst to search Using Outlook 0
H Custom Outlook Contact Form VBA Outlook VBA and Custom Forms 1
P Outlook 2013 Calendar Archiving Using Outlook 0
D Connecting Gmail to Outlook 365 - My Setup not working Using Outlook 1
K Outlook tasks formatting Using Outlook 4
G Retention Policy for Outlook.com Deleted Items folder Using Outlook 0
S Problem Checking the available stores in my Inbox (Outlook VBA) Outlook VBA and Custom Forms 0
V Is it possible to collect statistics from Outlook forms? Outlook VBA and Custom Forms 1
Z Outlook 365 delete reminder you can’t make change to contents of this-read only folder Using Outlook 4
H I have no profile listed for Outlook! Using Outlook 9
S Outlook VBA How to adapt this code for using in a different Mail Inbox Outlook VBA and Custom Forms 0
S Macro for Loop through outlook unread emails Outlook VBA and Custom Forms 2
D Outlook 2016 how to use gmail account as source account for outlook 365 Using Outlook 9
Horsepower Contacts added from iPhone don't show up in Outlook Using Outlook 1
F Microsoft Outlook Connector 14.0.6123.5001 - Help! Using Outlook 6
A Outlook (and Office) 2019 Logging Using Outlook 2
glnz Can Word Normal.dotm interfere with Outlook? Office 2016 Using Outlook 5
D Outlook 2016 and Earlier with Office365 in 2021 Using Outlook 3
glnz Moving from Outlook 2003 to MS365 Outlook - need basics Using Outlook 4
L Outlook saved template function too limited Using Outlook 2
C Looking for feedback on new Outlook Add-in Using Outlook 0
M Outlook on 3 Computers Shows Different Total Items on Same Account Using Outlook 3
S Outlook email to configure setup for each mail Outlook VBA and Custom Forms 1
witzker print-list-of-outlook-folders with sort posibility Outlook VBA and Custom Forms 7
witzker Open Contact missing in Outlook 2019 Using Outlook 2
D.Moore VB script to Digitaly Sign newly created outlook message Outlook VBA and Custom Forms 2
B Outlook 2016 Retail C2R keeps logging since update? Using Outlook 0
M outlook 365 trying to finish my sentences Using Outlook 0
D Outlook Address Book Using Outlook 0
B Emails get stuck in Outbox of Gmail IMAP in Outlook for Windows Using Outlook 0
C Not sync folders not found after MS Outlook 365 update Using Outlook 1
V Outlook 2016 Does Outlook-2016 (64 bit) work with iCloud for Windows ? Using Outlook 5
R Microsoft Outlook 2016 - Gmail not sending, asks for password for SMTP, tried different ports Using Outlook 23
V Outlook 2016 Outlook-2016 and iCloud for Windows - Problems Using Outlook 3
O VBA Outlook Message Attachment - Array Index Out of Bounds Outlook VBA and Custom Forms 0
K Imap PC Outlook + Android phone Using Outlook 1
GregS Outlook 2016 Move Outlook to new computer? Using Outlook 4
I Outlook 2003 shows html code when To: field is empty Using Outlook 7
O The Outlook API wrongfully shows an outlook folder to have zero sub-folders Outlook VBA and Custom Forms 1
O The Outlook API wrongfully shows an outlook folder to have zero sub-folders Outlook VBA and Custom Forms 2
C All Gmails don't show in Outlook 2019 Using Outlook 3
D Outlook 2007 vs. Outlook 2010 -- ToDo Bar Using Outlook 0
U Outlook 2016 Outlook 2016 sender name Using Outlook 1
T Compuserve, Yahoo, Oath2 and Outlook 2013 Using Outlook 4
E Work uses live accounts for emails for all employees. Can we use the outlook calendar to give the employees an universal work schedule calendar? Using Outlook 1
witzker Macro to move @domain.xx of a Spammail to Blacklist in Outlook 2019 Outlook VBA and Custom Forms 7

Similar threads

Top