Rules - many or few

Status
Not open for further replies.

Richard Flack

New Member
Outlook version
Outlook 2013 64 bit
Email Account
IMAP
Is it better to have one rule for each selection criterion (basically, "from") or to group by action (eg move to "keep 90 days" folder, with multiple selections)? Im thinking mainly about execution efficiency if theres a material difference in elapsed time. Absent that, seperate rule for each sender is probably easier to manage.
 

Diane Poremsky

Senior Member
Outlook version
Outlook 2016 32 bit
Email Account
Office 365 Exchange
Unless you have a lot of rules, individual rules are fine. But when you get more - around 50, maybe 100, combining rules might be better. If you used Exchange mailbox, you'd want to combine rules as you would be limited in the total number of rules stored.

A second consideration is how much mail arrives at once - if you typically get one or two or just a few messages at once, it won't really matter. But when you receive a lot of messages at once, rules can fail because Outlook can't process them fast enough. The only solution is fewer rules.

Rules don't always work good with imap accounts (but should be better with Outlook 2013, since it only downloads full messages) - if you find separate rules don't seem to work 100% of the time, try combining them and see if its better.
 

Richard Flack

New Member
Outlook version
Outlook 2013 64 bit
Email Account
IMAP
Again, thanks! I am using IMAP, but (usually) msgs arrive in dribs and drabs. The 'server' is Yahoo mail .... fpr some reason the blog wont let me cite the mail domain.
 

Diane Poremsky

Senior Member
Outlook version
Outlook 2016 32 bit
Email Account
Office 365 Exchange
Dribs and drabs should be ok.

Thanks for mentioning the url problem. I'll check the setting - we recently moved to new forum software and are working on configuring it to prevent spam. I'm guessing the new spam filter is triggering on the domain, or it's triggering on your account - new members are supposed to be limited to 1 url for the first few posts but the new filter might be preventing even 1 url. (Now that your account is upgraded, you *should* be allowed to post urls.)
 

Richard Flack

New Member
Outlook version
Outlook 2013 64 bit
Email Account
IMAP
Thanks but its still blocking "sneaky url"
Actually I was only giving a partial url, the mail domain, from "at" onwards. As in

(... "at" rogers "spot" com) but using symbols
if you follow

PS: it actually blocks (literally) "dot" in the above , thats why I used "spot"
 

Diane Poremsky

Senior Member
Outlook version
Outlook 2016 32 bit
Email Account
Office 365 Exchange
I just spent some more time testing it - did not like the results. Back to the drawing board - which means we might have to wait for spammers to post then delete the posts. :( But that is better than making the forum harder to use by people already frustrated by Outlook.

Now you really, really should be able to post urls.
 

Richard Flack

New Member
Outlook version
Outlook 2013 64 bit
Email Account
IMAP
Life is never easy! BTW this is the "using outlook" forum I believe, is there a "trying to use Outlook forum"?
You can probably see the progression in my posts ... IMAP syncing is driving me nuts. The bizarre thing is that the MS fora are full of grumbles, nada from the microserfs, and a fair amount of guesswork and partial work arounds form the community. Looks like another case of MS having trouble breaking out of the corporate big iron / pc desktop mindset/

PS: testing that partial 'url' I was trying to cite ... Yahoo Mail (... @rogers.com)
 

Diane Poremsky

Senior Member
Outlook version
Outlook 2016 32 bit
Email Account
Office 365 Exchange
LOL. "Using" often means "trying to use" in outlook-land. (and I had two spams almost immediately after removing the last filter.)

IMAP is... better than it used to be. :) That should give you an idea of how bad it used to be. I do think Outlook 2013 is a step back, mostly because it removed the options to choose what imap folders to use for sent and deleted. Add a yahoo account to the mix... and it's another step back. I don't know what is going on with yahoo, but i often remove my yahoo account for a few weeks, just because the user/password dialog comes up all the time. I only use it for testing and can live without it for a while. It was pretty good since last fall when they made pop3 access free then it went downhill a couple of weeks ago.
 

Richard Flack

New Member
Outlook version
Outlook 2013 64 bit
Email Account
IMAP
Interesting. When you say "remove yahoo" do you just mean not signing in to web mail, or do you mean removing that account in Outlook? I dont have the latter option, Yahoo is the host or whatever for Rogers mail. I need IMAP cos of the iOS devices and keeping synced. Yes I get the password requests too not sure whats trigerring it.
Im making quite a jump from Outlook 2007 / Vista 32 bit (yes I actually had no issues with Vista) to 2013 win 7 64 bit. Thank goodness my new machine has the horsepower to cope.
 

Diane Poremsky

Senior Member
Outlook version
Outlook 2016 32 bit
Email Account
Office 365 Exchange
Remove it from Outlook because the user/password dialog was annoying. Unlike you, it's not my primary (or even secondary) account. Yahoo has had problems with the password dialog for probably 2 years - it goes away, then comes back. :(
 

Richard Flack

New Member
Outlook version
Outlook 2013 64 bit
Email Account
IMAP
Ok thanks. yes, ive got little choice. and yes ive had that problem before. Yahoo forum would be the place to lok for help?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Similar threads
Thread starter Title Forum Replies Date
K Multiple Rules on Single Email Using Outlook 2
Aussie Rules Run a Script on an Incoming Email OK and then the Email reverts Outlook VBA and Custom Forms 0
R rules not working - done troubleshooting Using Outlook 0
P Outlook 2013 All imported Mail Rules in error when imported into new profile Using Outlook 5
A Apply Selected Emails to outlook rules and Run Rules Using Outlook 5
Wayne Outlook locks up when opening "Manage Rules & Alerts" Using Outlook 7
T "Words In Recipient's Address" Rule Causes Outlook To Stop Processing Rules Using Outlook 3
Retired Geek Junk Folder Clean Up Rules Exchange Server Administration 1
B Setting rules Using Outlook 1
A rules not working Using Outlook 2
M Rules and autoreply Using Outlook 1
N Outlook rules don't create a copy for bcc'ed emails Using Outlook 3
O How to recover rules after switch from POP3 to IMAP Using Outlook 2
N Focussed Inbox Rules Failing Using Outlook 5
N Copies of emails from rules have wrong from: account Using Outlook 0
L Office 365 cloud based rules Using Outlook 1
K Outlook Rules: Move a Copy Using Outlook 4
CWM030 Rules disappearing in OL 2016? ( Yes, I searched before posting) Using Outlook 7
R When rules lose track of "specified folder" Using Outlook 6
I Outlook 2013 Rules - (client only) Using Outlook.com accounts in Outlook 1
B When I add more search strings to RULES, it is not processing them Using Outlook 3
O Having rules run on old mails noved to inbox Outlook VBA and Custom Forms 8
A rules (flags) not working Using Outlook 7
K Lost Rules. Assistant accesses my mailbox. Disappeared Using Outlook 0
soadfan Outlook rules look up display name only Using Outlook 4
S Send email via SMTP - use transport rules to add to senders inbox (then rule to move to sent items Exchange Server Administration 1
Justo Horrillo Issue with rules in Outlook 2010 Using Outlook 4
J Outlook Rules - Changing auto-submit address in multiple rules, according to rule name Outlook VBA and Custom Forms 0
R When rules are working but invisible and unmanageable Using Outlook 2
P Transport Agent or Rules/Connectors Exchange Server Administration 1
A Rules - how to determine if all conditions in rule are true or false Outlook VBA and Custom Forms 5
E Outlook 2010 need help with rules Using Outlook 0
O Rules and Alerts for New Messages BEFORE sending Using Outlook 2
D Outlook Rules Using Outlook 1
Diane Poremsky Autoaccept a Meeting Request using Rules New Slipstick.com Articles 2
K adding more rules to 'different domains check' macro Outlook VBA and Custom Forms 2
Gunny NFOhiway Outlook PST file and Rules Using Outlook 1
M Outlook 2016 Rules Not Working Automatically Using Outlook 5
Diane Poremsky Rules & Alerts Dialog Won't Open New Slipstick.com Articles 1
soadfan Enable all rules from toolbar button? Outlook VBA and Custom Forms 3
oliv- How to Run a Script IN AN ADDIN with Outlook's Rules and Alerts Outlook VBA and Custom Forms 2
P Log of Rules that ran Outlook VBA and Custom Forms 3
Q Outlook 2016\365 export specific rules to import in another system Exchange Server Administration 1
S Rules to auto redirect Using Outlook 5
P Recover / Extract Rules from standalone PST file creating RWZ file Using Outlook 2
T Client-side rules not working, but no error Using Outlook 1
R Missing Quick Steps and Rules Using Outlook 0
Diane Poremsky Delegates, Meeting Requests, and Rules New Slipstick.com Articles 0
A outlook 2007 how to chcek all rules ? Outlook VBA and Custom Forms 2
J Outlook Rules not show Master Category List Using Outlook.com accounts in Outlook 4

Similar threads

Top